Article 5: Young Chinese abroad launch Internet attacks against Western press over Tibet unrestThe Associated Press. March 30, 2008
BEIJING: Armed with nationalism and the Internet, young Chinese abroad have launched a wave of attacks accusing Western media of bias in reporting on unrest in Tibet and defending Beijing's crackdown. The outpouring of emotion is unprecedented in scale and force. China's rising international status and Beijing's success in portraying the violence as being motivated by Tibetan separatists has emboldened students and others to express views that are unpopular in their host countries, experts said. From YouTube videos to Facebook to Web sites created to criticize news reporting, the message is emphatic: Western media are irresponsible and Tibet will never be independent. "To all you bandwagon jumpers who know nothing about chinese history and to all you bashers, let me give you some solid FACTS why Tibet was, is and always will be a part of China," says the opening statement of a video on YouTube that the site says was viewed nearly 2 million times by Saturday. The protests, led by monks, began peacefully on March 10, the anniversary of a failed 1959 uprising against Chinese rule. They erupted in violence on March 14. The Chinese government says 22 people have died, while Tibetans abroad put the death toll at 140. The unrest has cast a harsh light on China just as it prepares for the Beijing Olympics. Foreign governments have called for restraint and for independent monitors to ensure human rights are respected. "Imagine everyday you open the news and it's all saying bad and biased words towards your motherland: crackdown, killing, burning," Liu Yang, a graduate student in biology at the University of Chicago, said in an e-mail. "I don't understand, they struggle for press freedom and fairness, but why would they lose their conscience now?" she wrote. "Isn't the media independent, instead of being a mouthpiece?" College professors and several students agreed the sentiment wasn't confined to just a few fervent patriots. "Most of my friends here hold similar views," said Kevin He, a doctoral candidate who is president of the Chinese Students and Scholars Association at UCLA. "I have been talking about this issue with people from other organizations across the North America. They pretty much share the same opinions." In China, the news has raised less fuss, due in part to media controls that keep most Chinese from seeing reports aside from the entirely state-controlled press. The fact that Chinese students in the West are unsympathetic to Tibetans should be no surprise, said Barry Sautman, a social scientist at the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology. "The fact that they're living and studying and maybe working in the U.S. or any other part of the West doesn't make them feel they should adopt the prevailing viewpoint, because it doesn't necessarily correspond with what they know about China and the Chinese," he said. One student involved with a pro-Beijing Facebook group said he has struggled to battle misconceptions about his native country. "I do believe I should represent China whenever I can and defend my country ... but it is disheartening sometimes because many people simply do not listen," said Chris Yao, who administers a group called "Tibet WAS, IS, and ALWAYS WILL BE a part of China," inspired by
the YouTube video. "Ever got angry from CNN news reports over the Tibet issue?" says a note on the page. "Well, let me tell you, you are not the only one!" The students and Chinese media have offered a handful of examples of what they say is bias among Western journalists. One Web site, http://www.anti-cnn.com, complained that several news outlets showed photos of police in Nepal scuffling with protesters and misidentified the security forces as Chinese. It accused U.S.-based CNN of improperly cropping a photo of Chinese military vehicles on its Web site to remove Tibetan rioters who were pelting the trucks with rocks. CNN insisted it has reported impartially. "CNN refutes all allegations by bloggers that it distorts its coverage of the events in Tibet to portray either side in a more favourable light," the network said in a statement. The photo of military vehicles "was used wholly appropriately," the statement said. It said there should be no confusion because the image was captioned, "Tibetans throw stones at army vehicles on a street in the capital Lhasa."Yao, 22, is a Chinese-born computer engineering student at Canada's Simon Fraser University. He has lived in the United States and Canada since age 10 but says his loyalties lie with China. He plans to return after graduation.
Chay Teng's Commentary: This article is more about the Western media's/the West's portrayal of China, rather than the Tibet issue. Many times, the West have slammed China on some of its policies. While I may not necessarily agree with China's policies, I have to say that the West may be overly critical and sometimes, even hypocritical. The fact is that culturally and socially, East and West have grown to be quite different. So whatever the West make of China, they should perhaps step back and think about the situations, influences and circumstances that make the government react the way they do and not criticise just because what the Chinese government does does not correspond with what they think is right. After all, just because one party is right does not mean that the other party is wrong. There is more than one way to deal with any issue. Labels: international relations, posted by chay teng, Social, transnational issues
0 comments | comment?
